最高法院拒绝审理马里兰州敏感场所持枪禁令挑战 Thomas大法官附声明表示怀疑

美国最高法院11月16日拒绝审理对马里兰州「敏感场所」持枪禁令的挑战,维持联邦第四巡回上诉法院支持该州限制的裁定。马里兰州法律禁止在政府建筑、公共交通、学校、体育场馆、酒吧、医院、州立公园等一系列场所携带枪支,最高法院不予受理后,这些禁令继续有效。
本案案卷号25-1324,案名为 Novotny 诉 Moore。最高法院在当天的命令清单中驳回了持枪权利倡导者的调卷复审请求,没有就禁令是否合宪作出实体裁决。第四巡回上诉法院今年1月20日的裁定因此继续有效,该院此前支持了受挑战的绝大部分敏感场所禁令。
大法官 Clarence Thomas 随驳回命令附了一份声明。他表示,自己怀疑马里兰州的这些限制是否符合美国枪支管制的历史传统,也就是2022年 Bruen 案确立的审查标准;他警告说,如果把「敏感场所」扩大到一切公众聚集之地,将掏空公众为自卫携带武器的一般权利。不过 Thomas 也同意本案不受理,理由是这项挑战范围太宽、会使审查复杂化;他同时表示,在一件范围更聚焦的合适案件中,最高法院应当审议各州禁止携带枪支的权限边界。
马里兰州这部法律由州长 Wes Moore 于2023年签署,是2022年最高法院在 Bruen 案中扩张持枪权利后,多个州出台新限制之一。法律禁止在大学校园、医院、电厂、游乐园、赌场,以及现场销售和饮用酒精或大麻的场所等地携带枪支,并延续了该州在公共交通、学校和公共抗议现场周边等场所的长期禁令。提出挑战的一方包括马里兰州的持枪居民与持枪权利组织。
最高法院定于12月2日审理另一起挑战各州突击式步枪禁令的案件,届时大法官们将有机会就第二修正案的适用范围再次表态。
Supreme Court Declines to Hear Challenge to Maryland Sensitive-Places Gun Bans, With a Statement From Thomas
The U.S. Supreme Court on November 16 declined to hear a challenge to Maryland's bans on carrying firearms in so-called sensitive places, leaving in place a federal appeals court ruling that upheld the restrictions. The Maryland law bars guns in places including government buildings, mass transit, schools, stadiums, bars, hospitals and state parks, and those bans remain in force after the Court turned the case away.
The case is Novotny v. Moore, No. 25-1324. In its November 16 order list, the Court denied the gun-rights advocates' petition for review without deciding whether the bans are constitutional. The U.S. Court of Appeals for the Fourth Circuit's January 20, 2026 ruling therefore stands; that court had upheld nearly all of the sensitive-place bans that were challenged.
Justice Clarence Thomas attached a statement respecting the denial. He said he is skeptical that Maryland's restrictions are consistent with the nation's historical tradition of firearm regulation, the test set by the Court's 2022 Bruen decision, and warned that expanding the sensitive-place category to all places of public congregation would eviscerate the general right to carry arms in public for self-defense. Thomas agreed with denying this case, however, saying the challenge was so sweeping that it would complicate review, and he said the Court should consider the scope of states' authority to ban firearms in an appropriate, more narrowly focused case.
Maryland's law was signed in 2023 by Governor Wes Moore and was one of several state measures enacted after the Supreme Court's 2022 Bruen ruling expanded gun rights. It prohibits guns on college campuses, in hospitals, power plants, amusement parks and casinos, and in places that sell alcohol or cannabis for on-site consumption, building on the state's longstanding restrictions covering public transit, schools and areas near public demonstrations. The challengers included Maryland gun owners and gun-rights groups.
On December 2, the Court is scheduled to hear a challenge to state bans on assault-style rifles, giving the justices another occasion to address the reach of the Second Amendment.
来源:美国最高法院
发布:GSM·美国(发布链接)
图片来源:图:位于 Annapolis 的马里兰州议会大厦(Martin Falbisoner 摄,CC BY-SA 3.0,经 Wikimedia Commons 取得)。 / Image: The Maryland State House in Annapolis (Martin Falbisoner, CC BY-SA 3.0, via Wikimedia Commons).
GSM Global · 本篇英文版 English edition of this story

