最高法院拒绝受理司法部上诉:第五巡回「毒品轻罪前科禁枪违宪」裁定维持

华盛顿10月5日——据法律媒体与枪支政策组织10月5日的消息,美国最高法院当日拒绝受理司法部的一项调卷请求(cert petition):司法部请求复审联邦第五巡回上诉法院的一项裁定,该裁定推翻了查尔斯·亨布里(Charles Hembree)「重罪犯持有枪支」的定罪。最高法院拒绝受理后,第五巡回的裁定在德克萨斯、密西西比与路易斯安那三州范围内维持效力。
第五巡回三人合议庭(两名特朗普任命法官、一名奥巴马任命法官)于1月27日裁定,就亨布里2018年持有甲基苯丙胺(冰毒)的定罪而言,对其适用重罪犯禁枪条款违反第二修正案。此案与最高法院此前在Hemani案中的判决同属「特定前科人群持枪权」的 as-applied(按个案情形)挑战系列:Hemani案中,最高法院推翻了对一名经常使用大麻者的枪支指控。
枪支政策联盟(Firearms Policy Coalition)10月5日在社交平台公布了拒绝受理的消息,并将其称为持枪权一方的一次胜利。需要区分的是,拒绝受理调卷不等于最高法院对实体问题作出判决:它只是不审理本案,巡回法院裁定因此在本辖区有效,其他巡回区的同类冲突仍待未来案件解决。
信息来源:Liberty Unyielding 10月7日报道(消息源为10月5日法院命令清单);枪支政策联盟10月5日公告。
图片来源:Courtroom Gavel - Judge - Court Hearing — weiss_paarz_photos / CC BY-SA 2.0 (via Openverse)
Supreme Court Declines DOJ Appeal, Leaving Fifth Circuit Ruling That Felon Gun Ban Was Unconstitutional as Applied
WASHINGTON, Oct. 5 — The Supreme Court on Monday declined to hear the Justice Department's petition to review an appeals court decision that overturned Charles Hembree's conviction for possessing a firearm as a felon, according to legal outlets and gun-rights groups reporting on Oct. 5. The refusal leaves the Fifth Circuit's ruling in force across Texas, Mississippi and Louisiana.
A three-judge Fifth Circuit panel — two Trump appointees and one Obama appointee — had ruled on Jan. 27 that applying the felon-in-possession ban to Hembree, whose underlying conviction was a 2018 methamphetamine possession offense, violated the Second Amendment as applied to him. The case belongs to a line of as-applied challenges following the Supreme Court's ruling in Hemani v. United States, which struck down a gun charge against a regular marijuana user.
The Firearms Policy Coalition announced the denial on Oct. 5 and called it a win for gun rights. A denial of certiorari is not a ruling on the merits: it simply means the court will not take the case, so the circuit decision stands within its circuit while conflicts elsewhere await future cases.
Source: Liberty Unyielding, Oct. 7, reporting the Oct. 5 orders list; Firearms Policy Coalition announcement, Oct. 5.
Photo: Courtroom Gavel - Judge - Court Hearing — weiss_paarz_photos / CC BY-SA 2.0 (via Openverse)
图片来源:图:美国最高法院大楼正面。摄影:Jesse Collins,CC BY 3.0,来源:Wikimedia Commons

